Athena takes a nervous step back as soon as Raylan's gun comes out, eyes wide. It's one thing to do a little subtle manipulation as an easy prank. She didn't think this guy would connect her smugness to the abnormal movement of the door.

Which is when it clicks for her who this has to be.

"Holy fuck, you're the guy." Her voice comes out tiny. She clears her throat, straightens up a little, very clearly trying to steel herself in that particular way that teenagers think is subtle and definitely isn't.

She still stays behind Raylan this time.